Metro tragedy

Who is to blame for Mexico City's metro tragedy and what are the repercussions?

An independent investigation, carried out by the Norwegian consultancy DNV, into the collapse of the Linea 12 metro line in Mexico City, has pointed to structural flaws as the cause of the accident. The preliminary inquiry described how a lack of bolts, badly executed welding, loss of shape on beams and the use of different types of concrete all contributed to the fatal outcome.

A senior figure at the Metro Union was disappointed by the findings, “It [the report] was handwashing, almost blaming the bricklayers, as if there was no blame for a lack of supervision, for mismanagement of construction, for poor maintenance and so on. It was not a surprise though, we were never confident that there would be a real investigation to punish the culprits.”

“It was handwashing, almost blaming the bricklayers, as if there was no blame for a lack of supervision, for mismanagement of construction, for poor maintenance and so on.”

Metro Union representative, Mexico

Speculation around the identity of these senior ‘culprits’ centred around: Marcelo Ebrard – the current Minister of Foreign Affairs and the former Mayor of Mexico City when Linea 12 was constructed, Claudia Sheinbaum – the current Mayor of Mexico City and Grupo Carso – the Mexican conglomerate, owned by Carlos Slim, that constructed the line.

Ebrard and Sheinbaum were once tipped as potential successors to President Andrés Manuel López Obrador, but no more as a political analyst explained, “Ebrard is keeping a low profile, he will spend a season in exile to clear the air, if he can rebuild his image he may try to run in 2024. Sheinbaum is in a much worse position, she is also burdened by decisions around COVID, she looks tired. The one advantage for both is that AMLO likes them, he will weave a narrative to exonerate them both.”

“Ebrard is keeping a low profile, he will spend a season in exile to clear the air […] Sheinbaum is in a worse position.”

Political analyst, Mexico

The political analyst continued to outline how AMLO was already changing the narrative, “It is not convenient for AMLO’s friends to come out badly from this. They [the government] have already succeeded in shutting down the voices of those who are demanding justice, by bringing up other topics to divert the attention of the media.” The Union representative was saddened by the government’s response, “What hurts is that the President is trying to minimise what happened, making it seem like the whole tragic accident was somehow a plot against him. They believe money will compensate for the pain but we won’t forget the 26 dead or the wounded.”

The public prosecution office of Mexico City has opened its own investigation which will likely determine the imposition of fines and sanctions on those responsible for the accident. At the same time, victims have started legal action to seek compensation. Grupo Carso would be the obvious target, as the Metro Union representative explained, “I don’t think it will go beyond a large fine for Grupo Carso, nothing that will harm [Carlos] Slim’s reputation”

Grupo Carso has stated that it will not make any comments until the final investigative report is released.

Ebrard said that he supports all inquiries into the accident but claimed that, in addition to the technical report, inquiries should review the entire decision-making process in the design, layout, supervision and maintenance of the work.

Important Notice
While the information in this article has been prepared in good faith, no representation, warranty, assurance or undertaking (express or implied) is or will be made, and no responsibility or liability is or will be accepted by Deheza Limited or by its officers, employees or agents in relation to the adequacy, accuracy, completeness or reasonableness of this article, or of any other information (whether written or oral), notice or document supplied or otherwise made available in connection with this article. All and any such responsibility and liability is expressly disclaimed.
This article has been delivered to interested parties for information only. Deheza Limited gives no undertaking to provide the recipient with access to any additional information or to update this article or any additional information, or to correct any inaccuracies in it which may become apparent.

Most recent in Infrastructure

The need to restructure infrastructure

Transforming infrastructure in Latin America.

Roseau’s Renaissance

The Roseau Enhancement Project and its complexities in Dominica.

Transforming Brazil’s aviation landscape

Challenges and opportunities in the new growth acceleration programme. 

Mexico’s ‘megareforma’

Balancing public interests and investors' concerns.

Turbulent recovery

Caribbean airports refurbished as international flights return to pre-pandemic levels but regional flights lag.

Smart stadiums

Could technology in use at the World Cup transform Latin America’s stadiums?

Sustainable roadways

Could post-pandemic investment in sustainable road infrastructure plug Latin America’s infrastructure gap?

Aging infrastructure

Floods highlight decades of underinvestment in water infrastructure in the Dominican Republic.

Dollar threat

A strong dollar presents a risk to Colombia’s import-dependent construction industry.

Reinventing the city

Cities across Latin America are investing in urban reform projects to revitalise city centres.